New York's highest court has a seat opening in February.

Governor Hochul and the State Senate get to choose who fills it. On a court this closely divided, one judge decides whether New Yorkers’ rights grow or disappear — at the exact moment federal courts are tearing them up.

We’re a statewide coalition demanding a Court of Appeals that fights for us.

7 judges

Decide the law for 20 million New Yorkers.

Feb. 10, 2027

Judge Jenny Rivera’s current term ends and the vacancy opens.

1 vote

Is often the whole difference.

Why This Matters

Seven people decide the law for 20 million New Yorkers.

Almost nobody is watching who gets appointed to this court. That’s a problem.

Inside the Court of Appeals, 20 Eagle Street, Albany.

The Court of Appeals shapes the laws that govern every New Yorker’s life, including what police can do without a warrant, whether tenants can stay in their homes, the extent and strength of workers’ rights, and much more.

The Court of Appeals has the final word on questions of New York law. Its rulings are incredibly consequential because they interpret how state laws are implemented and they’re binding precedent on lower courts across the state.

That means the judges on the Court of Appeals shape not only how New York law operates in courtrooms throughout the state, but how it exists everywhere in our everyday lives: in our workplaces and homes; in interactions with police, corporations, and employers; and when we’re trying to uphold our rights. Its decisions define the extent of our fundamental liberties and shape how we experience relationships of power imbalances.

The Supreme Court has dismantled rights that New Yorkers once counted on, and it’s showing no sign of stopping or changing course.

New Yorkers have watched with horror as the Supreme Court takes away rights we thought were settled, overruling common-sense state laws, undercutting New York’s sovereignty, and weakening the democratic institutions that hold power accountable.

When federal laws no longer protect our rights, state constitutions and courts are our remaining protection. New York’s can — and must — provide protections that the federal constitution no longer does.

Under former Chief Judge Janet DiFiore, the Court of Appeals repeatedly narrowed rights and ruled against workers, tenants, immigrants, and people accused of crimes.

With DiFiore as Chief Judge, then-Governor Cuomo cemented a conservative majority that repeatedly ruled against workers, tenants, and immigrants; narrowed New Yorkers’ rights; and made it harder for the state to protect the environment.

Worse, it walked away from New York’s proud tradition of a robust state constitution. Instead of reading our state constitution as the independent, strong source of rights that it is, the Court of Appeals increasingly looked to federal courts’ interpretations of the federal constitution, importing the Supreme Court’s ever-narrowing interpretations into New York law. The result was a high court that too often made New York law less protective when New Yorkers needed it to do more.

Closely divided cases can turn on a single vote. The next appointment could shape New Yorkers’ rights — and New York law — for years to come.

New Yorkers need a Court of Appeals equal to this moment: one that protects rights in practice, treats the state constitution as an independent source of protection, and understands the law from the vantage point of the vulnerable people it affects: workers, tenants, immigrants, consumers, and anyone who might be stopped by police or charged with a crime.

We need a court that respects New York’s power to take on climate change and corporate abuse, and that treats constitutional rights as meaningful in practice.

On a seven-member court, one judge can decide whether rights expand or narrow, whether protections survive, and how our democracy is structured. The Commission on Judicial Nomination, Governor Hochul, and the State Senate have that choice in front of them right now.

What We're Demanding

We're demanding a Court of Appeals that more strongly protects all New Yorkers.

Commission on Judicial Nomination

Is reviewing applicants and will create a shortlist.

Send Governor Hochul a slate of judges and lawyers with demonstrated track records of defending all New Yorkers’ rights.

Governor Hochul

Must nominate someone from the shortlist.
 
Nominate someone who has a history fighting for workers, tenants, immigrants, and defendants, and who will read New York’s constitution as independent, not as a copy of the federal constitution.

State Senate

Will vote to confirm or reject the nominee.
 
Do what you did in 2023: Hold a robust hearing, ask the nominee hard questions about their record, and vote no if their answers aren’t good enough.

TAKE ACTION

Two minutes.
Join the campaign.

1

Tell Gov. Hochul what you want

Add your name to the demand for a Court of Appeals that protects all New Yorkers.

2

Bring your organization in

Add your organization to our statewide coalition.

3

Stay in it

Learn about developments in the campaign.

Who's In the fight

Here's who's in our growing coalition.

More than 115 organizations from across New York State have joined this fight. The logos below show only some of the organizations in our coalition, so see here for the full list.

Takes two minutes. We’ll reach out to you before we publicly list your organization.

Resources

All our letters, all our materials, every analysis.

Scrutinize’s tool for looking up how the court has ruled.

The standard we’re holding this appointment to.

What we’re asking to see in the shortlist.

Press

In the news

Press inquiries

Peter Martin
Center for Community Alternatives
pmartin@communityalternatives.org

Reuben Torres
Center for Community Alternatives

rtorres@communityalternatives.org

PAst Campaigns

We've won our campaigns before.

We’ve led coalitions that have defeated a Court of Appeals nominee and forced bad judges off the bench.

2023 • Won

We made Court of Appeals history—and won our demands

Our campaign defeated a Court of Appeals nomination for the first time ever, paving the way for Chief Judge Rowan Wilson.

2024 • Won

We forced a terrible judge to retire

Brooklyn judge Vincent Del Giudice had 19 excessive sentences overturned — more than double any other judge in the state.

2025 • Won

We made a Buffalo judge back down from trying to stay on the bench

Judge M. William Boller sought an exemption to New York’s judicial mandatory retirement age — but withdrew that after we drew attention to his record.

Stay In It

Get campaign updates.

Hear about developments in the appointment process — and when we have new campaign actions.